Achievement Update: Feedback Thread

[Tilithia]

It doesn't feel right to leave guild for achievement. and then you cant be sure youll get invited back. 24 h from update,i haven't seen anyone leave guild for that achievement yet,thankfully.
Im going to patiently wait for my turn to pay to treasury,or wait for change in achievement.

[MedusasSnakes]

Huh, I've seen quite a few doing it today, even sent some invites to people to get them back.

I guess it doesn't seem like that big of a deal to me.

If 5 or 6 go a day, then invited back immediately, yeah, it's 24 hours, but if your guild is solid, it shouldn't cause too much havoc.

That's just my opinion, and yes, I was one who left a guild, donated a mill, and was invited back in.

[MedusasSnakes]

Yes, I'm double posting, but this is something completely different.

For the Gambler achievement "Rip-Off", keep picking the middle cup over and over again, and it will give you the 3 wins in a row.

My guild leader on w1 tested it on all 4 of his servers, and I tested it on two of the three I play on (after I post this, I'm going to go do it on my other server) - he said the max time it took him was 16 minutes.

[Ailacca]

Originally Posted by MedusasSnakes

Yes, I'm double posting, but this is something completely different.

For the Gambler achievement "Rip-Off", keep picking the middle cup over and over again, and it will give you the 3 wins in a row.

My guild leader on w1 tested it on all 4 of his servers, and I tested it on two of the three I play on (after I post this, I'm going to go do it on my other server) - he said the max time it took him was 16 minutes.

You should have about 3,7% chance to hit 3 in a row no matter what you pick.
If it's really random, it is (1/3)^3, so 1/27.

That is, if math memory didn't fail me.

[okk]

is Reliable working for everyone?

the counter does not seem to be incrementing to me even though today I launched a guild attack, attacked the guild portal, donated money and talked in chat. it still shows 0 of 10 days.

[Leander]

The Reliable achievement does not work at the moment. As today is a festivity in Germany I will get more information tomorrow.

The Gambler is pure luck. I lost much gold without winning before the update and also during beta testing but then I got the achievement on my FIRST attempt! Although it is pure luck and the chance is quite low (1/27), I thought the cup with the ball is brighter than the other cups...and won! Later, I wanted to try again but failed miserably. ... so I was just really lucky!

[Tilithia]

Use /gold bet 1 (in guild chat,with gambler window open) to not lose fortune on this achievement! :-)

[Sersemina]

The "leave guild and donate somewhere else" is not an official achievement. It is some workaround to a problem that most old servers have - full guild banks. I already left my guild, created a new one and donated. I came back a few minutes later and started my Naturism challenge because I couldn't join the guild battles for 24 hours anyways. I am happy I am done with this now and I am +10 all attributes ahead.

I am surprised we have the scrapbook change. I think we used to have 2014 items total and now they are 2022. Do you know where the new ones come from?

ps. BMWGuinness, I am still 99.01% scrapbook

[Fullmetal]

For the guild donation, why can't we just up the amount a guild can hold past 10 million? They did it for characters a while back with no issues... would make this achievement much simpler for everyone.

[Leander]

The scrapbook had a bug that did not count all items / displayed a wrong percentage. It has been fixed now BUT the number is still wrong. A solution is already in the works.